Skip to content
GLP-1 Scorecard
Menu
Site position #67

Collective

By Dana WhitfieldUpdated

Collective pairs $59 semaglutide and $69 tirzepatide with a required $199 annual membership, with care messaging and cold shipping included.

Our take

Collective is worth comparing for ongoing self-pay care: its low refill prices can justify the annual membership. For a short commitment, the $199 access fee makes it less attractive. The unpriced prescription-transmission fee needs an answer before the advertised savings become a dependable budget.

Visit Collective ↗We may earn a commission through these links, at no extra cost to you. Commercial relationships affect placement, but never the WeighScore or our editorial findings. See our disclosure.
Semaglutide
$59/mo (plus a required $199/year membership that renews annually)
Tirzepatide
$69/mo (plus a required $199/year membership that renews annually)
Coverage
44 states; excludes AL, CA, LA, MA, MS and WA
Brand-name
Not confirmed

Weigh Collective against the full graded field on the best semaglutide providers scorecard, or line it up against its closest alternatives. If you are considering a compounded option, read about whether compounded semaglutide is legit and safe.

Medication and annual membership are separate. A possible prescription-transmission charge remains unpriced; no all-in six-month total is verified.

The bargain starts with a membership decision

Collective advertises compounded semaglutide at $59 a month and tirzepatide at $69, at every dose, alongside a required $199 annual membership. That is an appealing starting point for a price comparison. It is also two separate purchases, and I would judge them together. A cheap refill cannot tell you whether the cost of joining makes sense for the time you actually expect to use the service.

The membership makes this a longer-term purchase. Someone still evaluating the service should pay particular attention to the trial deadline. The cheapest refill is not necessarily the cheapest way to try a new provider.

Put the trial deadline in your calendar

The 21-day trial waives membership charges, while medication still costs money. Collective says cancellation before that deadline avoids the annual fee. Its terms then provide for annual automatic renewal and generally exclude membership refunds, including refunds for unused portions of a year. Canceling after payment therefore does not ordinarily recover the remaining membership cost.

I would treat the trial as time to evaluate the service and understand the account, not as a reason to stop reading. Keep the cancellation confirmation if you decide against continuing. The useful question is how much flexibility you retain after the first membership payment, rather than how easy the signup appears.

One fee still needs an answer

The terms allow a technology transaction charge for electronically transmitting a prescription but do not give its amount. They also make purchases generally nonrefundable, subject to stated exceptions. Ask whether that transmission charge applies to the proposed order and request the complete amount before authorizing payment. An unspecified charge belongs in the unanswered column of a comparison.

Check availability before doing the math

Collective currently lists 44 states, excluding Alabama, California, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Mississippi and Washington. Membership includes doctor messaging, check-ins, nutrition support and express cold shipping. The homepage and terms reviewed do not name the dispensing pharmacy. That name is something I would want before committing, rather than infer from a general assurance about licensed pharmacies.

Collective gets my qualified recommendation for ongoing care, not a casual trial. Accepting the membership structure is one decision; accepting an unexplained charge or an unnamed dispensing pharmacy is another. If the company cannot clarify those details, the cheap refill loses much of its appeal.

Factor breakdown

Each of the six graded dimensions. See the methodology.

Cost value70/100
Dose & formulation64/100
Clinical oversight79/100
Labs & monitoring73/100
Fulfillment93/100
Contract terms43/100

Strengths

  • Publishes flat medication prices across doses
  • Membership includes doctor messaging, ongoing check-ins and nutrition support
  • Express cold shipping is included
  • A 21-day membership trial is available; medication remains payable
  • Publishes the six states it does not currently serve

Where it loses points

  • The $199 annual membership is additional to medication
  • Membership renews automatically each year; fees generally are not refundable, including unused portions
  • Terms permit a prescription-transmission technology fee without pricing it
  • The reviewed public pages do not name the dispensing pharmacy
  • The reviewed pricing does not define a medication month as a calendar month or a four-week cycle

Bottom line — Grade C

Best for: Self-pay shoppers comfortable paying an annual access fee and checking the final prescription charges before enrolling.

Look elsewhere if: Anyone seeking a short trial without a membership decision, or living in one of Collective’s six excluded states.

Site position #67 of 542. Commercial relationships affect placement, not the score. See our featured provider, CoreAge Rx (#1), for comparison.

Closest here

The rankings grading nearest Collective — the realistic shortlist.

KERNX Health#98

A physician-led compounded GLP-1 program that names its prescribing clinicians and gates every charge behind a provider's approval, but keeps its dispensing pharmacy unnamed and runs no routine lab program.

Maves#99

Maves, operating under parent company Homera Health, is a performance-framed telehealth platform offering compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide for weight loss plus sermorelin for anti-aging, with positioning around fat loss, lean muscle, and energy.

Rivo Health#100

Rivo Health is a large nationwide GLP-1 telehealth program (115,000+ members, Trustpilot 4.7) offering compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide as both injections and oral options, starting around $149/mo for semaglutide and $199/mo for tirzepatide with deeper discounts on 3- and 6-month plans.

He & She MD#101

He & She MD is a nationwide telehealth weight-loss clinic offering doctor-prescribed GLP-1 medications: compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide (injectable or oral), with brand-name…

9amHealth#103

9amHealth (join9am.com) is a cardiometabolic telehealth platform offering whole-body care including weight management with FDA-approved branded GLP-1 medications such as Wegovy, Zepbound, and Saxenda, plus FDA-approved generics.

Allara Health#104

Allara Health (allarahealth.com) is an insurance-accepting telehealth platform focused on women's metabolic and hormonal health, including PCOS, serving 44 states plus DC.

The 24 rankings nearest this one

View full scorecard rankings →

Pricing/verification reflect Collective's public disclosures at last grading; the WeighScore is our editorial judgment per the methodology. Prices change — confirm on Collective's site. Not medical advice; see our disclosure.

← Back to the scorecard