Skip to content
GLP-1 Scorecard
Menu

Head-to-head · WeighScore

FormidableMD vs Open Water Rx

By GLP-1 ScorecardUpdated

FormidableMDFactor scores not reassessed.
Site position #78

Higher score

Open Water RxFactor scores not reassessed.
Site position #393

Lower score

Score comparison

FormidableMD has the higher recorded score — 73.2/100 to 58.8/100.

FormidableMD grades higher on WeighScore, our editorial score across cost value, dose & formulation, clinical oversight, labs & monitoring, fulfillment and contract terms. FormidableMD is a physician-led, cash-pay telehealth practice based in Florida offering GLP-1 weight-loss treatment — semaglutide and tirzepatide in both FDA-approved and compounded forms, plus oral options — alongside peptides, HRT/TRT, urgent care, labs, and nutrition coaching.

Before you choose

Before comparing the headline prices, the FormidableMD review and the Open Water Rx review set out the plan length, renewal date and extra fees behind each semaglutide figure in the table below, and the semaglutide cost page compares published rates across the field. A lower starting price can still mean a larger bill once a longer commitment or a separate membership is added.

If neither one fits, FormidableMD vs ShedRx and Layla vs Open Water Rx compare each of them with another graded program, and the list of alternatives to FormidableMD ranks the programs closest to FormidableMD on price, features and score. Those pages, like every entry in the review directory, use the same six graded factors, so the scores carry across.

Of the sellers that pay us a commission, the PlexusDx review covers one graded close to these two, at 67.7/100. That relationship never changes a grade, and the review lists what we could not verify.

We may earn a commission through these links, at no extra cost to you. Commercial relationships affect placement, but never the WeighScore or our editorial findings. See our disclosure.

Factor by factor

These are recorded editorial marks, not a measure of clinical outcomes. Current prices and terms may differ from those used in the marks. See the methodology.

Cost valueFormidableMD +8
56
48
Dose & formulationOpen Water Rx +10
78
88
Clinical oversightFormidableMD +34
88
54
Labs & monitoringFormidableMD +23
83
60
FulfillmentFormidableMD +30
72
42
Contract termsFormidableMD +6
61
55
FormidableMD · top barOpen Water Rx · bottom bar

The numbers

Swipe or scroll to compare both providers.

MetricFormidableMDOpen Water Rx
WeighScore73.2/10058.8/100
GradeCC
Site position#78#393
Semaglutide$169/mo (1 mg dose, compounded)$169/mo (one-month plan; $495 for 3 months; compounded)
Tirzepatide$199/mo (10 mg dose, compounded)$219/mo (one-month plan; $645 for 3 months; compounded)
Coverage1 stateCoverage not published
Brand-name accessYesYes
Oral / sublingualYesYes
FormidableMD

Site position #78 · C

Factor scores not reassessed.

Strengths

  • Transparent, published dose-by-dose pricing for semaglutide ($169-$269/mo) and tirzepatide ($199-$319/mo) with no membership or commitment
  • Offers both FDA-approved and compounded GLP-1s (plus oral options) from 503A pharmacies, with a real provider at every visit
  • Boutique physician-led model bundling labs, peptides, HRT/TRT and urgent care; FSA/HSA eligible

What to consider

  • Florida-focused telehealth — availability outside FL is not advertised, so out-of-state access is uncertain
  • Medication cost is on top of a $199 initial consultation and $99 follow-up visits (pay-per-visit, not an all-in monthly price)
  • The 503A compounding pharmacy partner is not named on the site
Open Water Rx

Site position #393 · C

Factor scores not reassessed.

Strengths

  • Combines weight-loss and longevity verticals in one brand
  • Established brand domain

What to consider

  • Limited public data — most details are gated behind signup or rendered only in JavaScript
  • Pricing not disclosed
  • GLP-1 options (semaglutide vs. tirzepatide, compounded vs. brand, injection vs. oral) not stated
  • States-served list not disclosed
  • Pharmacy partner not named

Featured provider

CoreAge Rx

CoreAge Rx scores 89.5/100 (B+). Advertises pricing across doses with no membership fee, but starting-price displays and FAQ payment/refund promises need to be reconciled with the selected plan and refund policy.

Commercial relationships affect this placement. The score comparison above is separate.

Prices and terms can change; confirm them with the provider. Our factor scores may reflect earlier assessments; see our methodology. Not medical advice; see our disclosure.

← Back to the scorecard